I wholeheartedly mean it when I say this..

These might be the best cookies I’ve ever had in my life.

Like not “these are good for Madison”… I mean actually insane.

Also, this isn’t even a storefront. This is a local baker out of Waunakee. So there’s a very real chance you either:

There is no “walk in and sit down” here.

This is:

It’s very much a low-key, local baker setup. Which honestly makes it better.

Feels like you found something you weren’t supposed to know about yet.

Cookies:
I’m not exaggerating, these might be the best cookies I’ve ever had. Perfect bake, insanely soft, rich flavor. Like… immediate “yeah these are different” after one bite.

Bagels:
Some of the freshest bagels you’ll get around Madison. Soft in the middle, slight crunch on the outside, and the cinnamon raisin had that swirl in every single bite. Didn’t even toast it and it still hit.

Sourdough:
This might’ve been the prettiest loaf I’ve ever seen. Crunchy, crackly crust on the outside, super soft and fluffy inside. I ate it plain and was still blown away.

Overall: every single thing I tried was at the top of its category. Cookies, bagels, sourdough… all of it.

If you’re anywhere near Madison…

You need to try Andi’s Bakes.

I don’t know how often she’s baking.
I don’t know how hard it is to get an order in.

But if you get the chance, take it.

Start with the cookies & the sourdough.
Then get everything else.

And if you somehow think they’re not the best cookies you’ve had… I genuinely want to hear about it.